Two oranges, one finish: the core difference
Orange Submarine and Toot Sweets are both creme nail polishes from Lights Lacquer, but they sit at opposite ends of the orange spectrum. Orange Submarine is a vermillion orange—a warm, red-leaning shade—while Toot Sweets is a bright tarte red. Both are fully opaque in one to two coats according to the catalog, so the real decision comes down to the color you want on your nails and how you plan to wear it.
Because both share the same creme finish and self-leveling formula, you can expect a similar application experience. The difference is in the undertone: vermillion reads as a true orange with a hint of red, while tarte red leans more toward a bright, juicy red-orange. If you are looking for a warm orange nail polish that still feels distinctly orange, Orange Submarine is the closer match. If you want a bright orange manicure that borders on red, Toot Sweets is the one.
Shade and coverage details from the catalog
- Orange Submarine: Vermillion orange polish with a creme finish; fully opaque in 1-2 coats. Vermillion is a warm orange with red undertones, so this is the more traditionally orange option of the two.

Orange Submarine - Toot Sweets: Bright tarte red with a creme finish; fully opaque in 1-2 coats. Tarte red is a bright red-orange, making this the bolder, red-leaning choice for a bright orange manicure.

Toot Sweets
Application and formula: what they share
Both polishes are described as self-leveling and highly pigmented, with full coverage in one or two coats. That means you can expect a smooth, even finish without needing multiple layers. Orange Submarine comes with an oval-stemmed, rounded wide paddle brush, which the catalog notes is designed for effortless application. Toot Sweets does not list a brush type in the supplied details, so if brush shape is important to you, Orange Submarine has the edge in documented information.
Both are 21-free and vegan and cruelty-free, and both are made in the USA. The ingredient lists are similar, with the same base solvents and film formers, though the colorants differ. Neither product record includes specific care or removal instructions beyond the general claim of easy removal and long-lasting wear for Orange Submarine. Toot Sweets does not list removal or wear claims in the supplied details, so treat those as unconfirmed for that shade.
Which orange fits your manicure plan?
Use this quick comparison to match the polish to the look you want.
- For a warm, true orange: Choose Orange Submarine. Its vermillion base keeps it firmly in orange territory while the red undertone adds warmth.
- For a bright, red-orange statement: Choose Toot Sweets. Its tarte red color is bolder and more red-leaning, ideal if you want a bright orange manicure with extra punch.
- If brush shape matters: Orange Submarine specifies a wide paddle brush for easy application. Toot Sweets does not list a brush type in the supplied catalog details.
- If you want documented wear claims: Orange Submarine lists easy removal and long-lasting wear. Toot Sweets does not include those claims in the supplied information.
Price and size: what the catalog shows
At the time of writing, Orange Submarine is listed at $9.10 (compare at $13.00) for 13 ml / 0.43 fl oz. Toot Sweets is listed at $8.97 (compare at $13.00), but its size is not provided in the supplied record. Both are in the same price range, so the decision should be based on shade and the details that matter to you rather than a significant cost difference.
What the catalog does not tell you
The supplied product records do not include swatches, dry time, or wear-test results for either polish. Toot Sweets also lacks a listed size and brush type. If you need those specifics before buying, check the full product pages or reach out to customer service. This comparison is based only on the catalog details provided, so consider it a starting point for your choice rather than a complete performance review.


